Failure Case Study: Dunkin' Donuts & More - Misaligned positioning kept the brand from forging a deeper connection with consumers

Failure Case Study: Dunkin' Donuts & More - Misaligned positioning kept the brand from forging a deeper connection with consumers

Summary

Dunkin' Donuts, a leading American quick-service restaurant (QSR) brand with worldwide presence, forayed into the Indian market in 2012 in collaboration with Jubilant FoodWorks Limited. Dunkin' Donuts customized its menu to suit the taste buds of young Indian consumers, and the pockets of middle-class households. It also revamped its stores, menu, and positioning to boost sales. However, in spite of store facelifts and a menu revamp, Dunkin' Donuts continued to struggle in the Indian market. Consequently, Dunkin' Donuts refocused its core offering and Jubilant began optimizing store counts and costs.

Dunkin' Donuts opened its first branch in India in 2012 under the name Dunkin' Donuts & More, with a more localized and broader menu than its US stores. Despite customizing the menu and revamping its store ambience, the company failed to make any meaningful gains, leading to the closure of about 50% of its stores by 2018.

Scope

- Dunkin' Donuts' core offering of doughnuts and coffee was not in sync with the Indian concept of breakfast as Indians are not familiar with the idea of having doughnuts for breakfast. Moreover, out-of-home breakfast occasions are few and far between in India.
- Dunkin' Donuts sidelined its beverages menu to focus only on food items and neglected its lucrative beverages line, which cost the company potential growth.
- While its localized menu drove sales, Dunkin' Donuts risked its brand identity as by expanding its menu, thereby losing its core differentiation from other QSRs.
- Multinational QSR brands need to think global and act local in their product positioning strategies, keeping their core brand identity intact while adapting product offerings for local tastes.
- Continual investment into market research and customer education is the key to understanding the needs of target consumers in new markets.

Reasons to buy

- Reduce the risk of failure by learning from brands/products that have under-performed: failed innovation can severely impact profit and reputation.
- Understand the relevant consumer trends and attitudes that drive and support innovation success so you can tap into what is really impacting the industry.
- Gain a broader appreciation of the fast-moving consumer goods industry by gaining insights from both within and outside of your sector.
- Access valuable strategic take-outs to help direct future decision-making and inform new product development.